I'll be the first to admit that I have a love/hate relationship with cover songs. Why ruin a good thing you've grown to love and appreciate? (And by grown to love and appreciate, I mean listen to on repeat about 50 times.) But the reality is there's likely another artist out there who can sing the song just as well...or better.
With singers like Lana Del Rey and Halsey creating the best new cover songs of 2019, decide for yourself whether the originals still make the cut, below.
Harry Styles - Lizzo's "Juice"
The internet lost its shit when Harry Styles covered one of Lizzo's original songs, "Juice." Now she needs to cover "Watermelon Sugar," and all will be right again in the world.
Sam Smith - Donna Summer's "I Feel Love"
Though you may have recognized their song from the Target holiday commercials, Sam Smith's cover of Donna Summer's "I Feel Love" means so much more to them. "As a queer person ‘I feel love’ has followed me to every dance floor in every queer space from the minute I started clubbing," Smith wrote on Instagram. "This song to me is an anthem of our community and it was an honour and most importantly so much fun to have a go at it. Highest song I've ever fucking sang. But a joy. I hope you all like it xx."
Ben Platt and Kelly Clarkson - Bob Dylan's "Make You Feel My Love"
My jaw completely dropped when I first heard Ben Platt and Kelly Clarkson's rendition of Bob Dylan's "Make You Feel My Love" on Clarkson's The Kelly Clarkson Show. Both artists can hit a high note like no other, and I want to be best friends with them.
Lana Del Rey - Sublime's "Doin' Time"
New Lana Del Rey fans will likely assume that "Doin' Time" is an original single, but in fact it's a cover of the 1996 Sublime hit. In classic Del Rey fashion, her version is slow, moody, and dare I say...better?
Boyce Avenue ft. Jennel Garcia - Camila Cabello and Shawn Mendes' "Señorita"
If you weren't watching Boyce Avenue's cover right now, you'd likely picture the lyrics coming straight from the mouths of Camila and Shawn. Here, the chemistry is key to the consistency.
Madilyn Bailey - Lewis Capaldi's "Someone You Loved"
Lewis Capaldi's "Someone You Loved" is the heartbreaking radio hit you can't stop playing, but Madilyn Bailey's version is the one that doesn't make you feel so bad about it. The emotion in the 27-year-old YouTube singer's voice radiates as she belts out lyrics like, "Now the day bleeds / Into nightfall / And you're not here / To get me through it all."
Halsey - Jonas Brothers' "Sucker"
It's safe to say Halsey is a JoBro fan. Her slow, blues-y rendition of the Jonas Brothers' "Sucker" is sensual, emotional, and a completely badass refresher to the fast dance beat fans are used to (while, of course, still allowing us to appreciate the original).
Weezer - Eurythmics' "Sweet Dreams (Are Made of This)"
Yes, this is Eurythmics' "Sweet Dreams (Are Made of This)" and yes, this is a cover of it by none other than Weezer. I don't make the rules.
Ben Platt - Joni Mitchell's "River
If you haven't watched Ryan Murphy's new Netflix show, The Politician, you're missing out on Ben Platt's beautiful rendition of Joni Mitchell's 1971 "River." Platt's character, Payton, adds an emotional depth to the cover listeners wouldn't understand by just hearing the audio, so do yourself a favor and watch it.
Keith Urban - Taylor Swift's "Lover"
Keith Urban was so obsessed with Taylor Swift's "Lover" from her album of the same title that he decided to cover it during one of his concerts. The day Swift released the song he tweeted, "Huge shoutout today to @taylorswift13 on the SUPERB new single LOVER. When a song so exquisitely written becomes a record so gorgeously crafted I feel such a deep sense of gratitude for the 'art' of making music."
For more stories like this, including celebrity news, beauty and fashion advice, savvy political commentary, and fascinating features, sign up for the Marie Claire newsletter.
RELATED STORIES
-
Madison Errichiello Is the 'Love Is Blind' Season 8 Standout Who Left the Pods Single—But We Haven't Seen the Last Of HerFans already have thoughts on the love square between her, Alex, Mason, and Meg.
-
Kylie Jenner Just Upstaged Timothée Chalamet at His Own PremiereValentine's Day came early for the couple.
-
Prince Archie and Princess Lilibet Will Likely Make Their Joint Royal Debut at this EventFans might have to wait a while.
-
Beyoncé Wins Album of the Year for the First Time Ever at the 2025 GrammysThe superstar—who has the most wins in the award show's history—took home the biggest prize of the night for 'Cowboy Carter.'
-
Chappell Roan Wins Best New Artist at the 2025 Grammys—And Called Upon Record Labels to Enact Artist Healthcare ReformThe Midwest Princess made a powerful speech while accepting the award for Best New Artist.
-
Doechii Wins Best Rap Album at the Grammys and Dedicates the Award to Black Women: "You're Exactly Who You Need to Be""The Swamp Princess" is the third female rapper to take home the gramophone.
-
RAYE Shares What Music Shaped Her—And What's on Her Playlist NowThe Best New Artist-nominated singer discusses Britney Spears, Charli xcx, and Nina Simone.
-
How Failure Felt Like "Business School" for Ashley Tisdale—And Helped Propel Her Brand ForwardThe actress, singer, and Frenshe founder speaks to editor-in-chief Nikki Ogunnaike for the 'Marie Claire' podcast "Nice Talk."
-
Let Ethel Cain's Defiance Guide You Through 2025In the wake of Donald Trump's re-election, the indie singer's outspokenness has become a balm for fans.
-
ROSÉ Is Forging a New Path for K-Pop Idols Going SoloWith her debut album 'rosie,' the BLACKPINK artist has released the most vulnerable album from a K-pop star yet.
-
TWICE Shares What Music Shaped Them—And What's on Their Playlist NowWith their new mini-album 'STRATEGY' out, the K-pop girl group opens up about their musical preferences for the 'Marie Claire' series "Listen Up."
