The Best Press-On Nails for a DIY Manicure, Tested by Editors

Everyone will think you went to the salon.

Model wearing press-on nails
(Image credit: Launchmetrics)

I’m not too proud to admit that I take every opportunity possible to save a few bucks on my nail routine. A $35 manicure every week adds up—quickly. Whether you’re opting for a simple winter nail polish or more elaborate gel-X extensions or builder gel, they’ll usually set you back a couple hundred a month and I'm personally not trying to shell out that kind of cash. That's where the best press-on nail sets enter the chat.

Press-ons provide the perfect solution—they’re cute, pretty easy to apply, and with the right application technique, last almost as long as an in-salon manicure. (It took me a while to warm up to press-ons because I could never seem to get the application process right, but now, as a beauty editor with access to the professionals, I’m happy to report that I have it down to a science.)

First, when choosing a set of press-ons, Los Angeles-based celebrity nail artist Brittney Boyce says there are a few things to keep in mind. “Quality is key when choosing a press-on nail set,” she tells Marie Claire. “Look for press-ons that aren't flimsy and have a well-defined shape. With nail art, it's usually easy to tell the quality just by looking at the design.”

In other words, don’t opt for the cheapest or thinnest-looking set. The absolute best press-on nails don’t skimp on quality and still manage to stay under the $20 mark. If you’re ready to try out a new look or color (may I suggest dark cherry red or mocha mousse), I’ve put together a complete guide to press-on nails below.

To create this guide, I’ve asked my fellow beauty editors for their all-time favorite press-on sets, consulted two celebrity nail artists, and test-drove the best ones myself to give you the full picture. You’ll also want to check out the FAQ at the end, which answers all of the most common questions regarding press-ons, including the best application method and how to remove them.

The Best Press-On Nails

Beauty editor Shawna Hudson tries Glamnetic Hailey Short Almond Press-On Nails

Beauty editor Shawna Hudson tries Glamnetic Hailey Short Almond Press-On Nails

(Image credit: Shawna Hudson)

Beauty editor Shawna Hudson tries Ardell French Nude Press-On Nails

Beauty editor Shawna Hudson tries Ardell French Nude Press-On Nails

(Image credit: Shawna Hudson)

Beauty editor Shawna Hudson tries Chillhouse Press-On Nails in Catch the Crown

Beauty editor Shawna Hudson tries Chillhouse Press-On Nails in Catch the Crown

(Image credit: Shawna Hudson)

Beauty editor Shawna Hudson tries Lost Angels You Wish Press-On Nails

(Image credit: Shawna Hudson)

Other Press-On Nails I Love

What Are Press-On Nails?

Boyce explains that press-on nails are pre-made nail covers (with or without a nail extension) that can be applied onto your natural nail for salon-quality nails in minutes—and last two weeks or longer. Celebrity nail artist Elle Gerstein notes that, "tabs are easy to apply but don't have incredible staying power, whereas glue can last anywhere from seven to 10 days."

How to Use Press-On Nails

Both Gerstein and Boyce say the main thing you’ll want to make sure of before applying press-ons is that your nails are squeaky clean and dry. Boyce recommends washing your hands, pushing back your cuticles, gently buffing the nails, and wiping them with a cleansing alcohol pad first. This will ensure that your press-on nails adhere properly and last as long as possible.

Next, you’ll want to select the best size for each of your nails and set them in a pattern so you know which press-on matches each nail. If you’re like me and your nails are different sizes on each hand, you’ll definitely want to size each nail individually and not just use the same sizes you picked for the opposite hand. Then, it's time to apply your nails.

For Glue Application

If you’re using glue, Boyce says to apply a dot of glue on both the press-on and your natural nail, then align the press-on with your cuticle. Push down at a 45-degree angle for 45 seconds. Some glue takes a lot longer to fully dry and you may have to press firmly on the nail for more than a minute. Let your nails then dry fully and avoid getting water, oil, or lotion on them for a few hours.

For Adhesive Application

If you’re using adhesive tabs, you’ll go through the same prep process, but this time, you’ll select the best press-on nail and find the matching adhesive tab size. You’ll want to apply the adhesive side of the tab on the natural nail and then peel off the film from the tab. Then, you’ll align the press-on extension with the cuticle and push down firmly at a 45-degree angle. Rub the center and then the sides of the extension to fully secure the adhesive.

How Long Do Press-On Nails Last?

How long your press-on nails last will definitely depend on proper prep and application, but if you do it correctly, they can last just as long as an in-salon manicure. According to Gerstein, press-ons with adhesive nail tabs don’t last as long as options with nail glue, usually only lasting anywhere from three to five days. Boyce says that when using nail glue, your press-ons can last 14 plus days if you prep your nails properly using the above tips.

How to Remove Press-On Nails

To remove adhesive tab press-ons, Gerstein says rubbing alcohol is required. “The alcohol will quickly release the adhesive for an easy cleanup,” she explains. “Glue requires cutting the tip all the way down and then soaking in pure acetone nail remover for 25 minutes. Patience is required—about 30 minutes.”

Boyce also has her own helpful method. “Once extensions start to lift, soak them in warm, soapy water for five minutes. Gently rock the extension side to side until it completely detaches," she says. Do not force extensions off nails. Boyce also mentions that cuticle oil works well for removing adhesive tabs. Rub some around the edges of the press-ons and wait 60 seconds.

Why Trust Marie Claire

Marie Claire is an expert on all nail-related topics, covering everything from the latest celebrity manicures to the season's hottest nail colors and trends.

Beauty writer Shawna Hudson brings five years of expertise to this story and has tested almost every major brand of press-on nails on the market. She spoke to two experts for more tips and insight on press-ons for this story.

How I Tested

For this story, I sourced editor favorites, drawing on past and present experiences with different press-on nail sets and tested over 15 sets to ascertain our top picks. We also dove into customer reviews and selected the most highly-rated options on the market. We also evaluated each option for ease of application, durability, and how long each pair lasted without chipping or popping off.

Meet the Experts

Celebrity nail artist Brittney Boyce
Brittney Boyce

Brittney Boyce is a Los Angeles-based nail artist and founder of press-on nail brand Lost Angels. She brings over 10 years of experience in the nail industry to this article and has created many iconic celebrity nail looks for award shows and photoshoots. Her celebrity clients include Megan Fox, Charli D’Amelio, Kim Kardashian, and BLACKPINK’s Rosé.

Cebelrity nail artist Elle Gerstein
Elle Gerstein

A natural born nail artist, Elle Gerstein opened her own business at age 17, with over 80 clients per week. Now one of the industry's top artists, she is world renowned for her cutting-edge nail shaping, and her understanding of color, texture and trends. For Elle, nail styling means creating the ultimate glamour. Her celebrity clientele includes Lindsay Lohan, Angelina Jolie, Blake Lively, and Kelly Ripa.

Shawna Hudson
Contributing Beauty Writer

Shawna Hudson has been writer for over 10 years covering beauty, wellness, and lifestyle. She graduated from California State University, Fullerton, with a degree in journalism and her work has appeared in other publications such as Who What Wear, Bustle, Refinery 29, The Zoe Report, Byrdie, PS, and more. Most of her spare time is spent doing Korean face masks and testing every new high-tech hair tool possible. Stay up to date on her latest finds on Instagram @shawnasimonee.