The 15 Best Concealers for Mature Skin Won't Sink Into Under-Eye Creases

Hydrating formulas are key.

best concealers
(Image credit: Future)

The best concealers are capable of oh-so-many things. Some can brighten, while others are the best color-correctors. A few cover redness or are capable of decreasing under-eye puffiness with a hint of caffeine and a metal applicator. But, as we age, there are added factors to consider when choosing a coverage product. The best concealers for mature skin must be lightweight (cakiness is avoidable) and deeply hydrating to prevent product from settling into little lines. Thankfully, the concealer sector, which is expected to be worth a shocking $12 billion by 2031, is constantly releasing new formulations—and revamping existing items to perform at a higher standard.

In the past year, Charlotte Tilbury and Fenty entered the concealer game for the first time, while Anastasia Beverly Hills and Estee Lauder expanded their current offerings. Of course, brands like NARS and YSL have amassed a cult following (including yours truly, Jennifer Lopez, and Kendall Jenner) for their seemingly magical concealers that work to brighten, highlight, and color correct. Those few just make up the highlight reel.

Read ahead to get the full breakdown on the concealers in my personal collection (I’ve tested well over 100 formulas, FYI) and those loved by makeup artists and celebrities. That's not all, though. We also had five women over 45 put these products to the test—and share their honest thoughts.

The Best Concealers for Mature Skin

Mindy Holender wearing armani concealer with a black top in a dark background.

Mindy Holender wears Armani Luminous Silk Face and Under Eye Concealer in shade 1.5.

(Image credit: Mindy Holender)

Darlese Robinson wearing Bobbi Brown's concealer stick in a coral top.

Darlese Robinson wears Bobbi Brown's Concealer Stick in shade Golden.

(Image credit: Marie Claire)

Marcia Perry Dix wearing NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer in shade Hazelnut with red lipstick and a white shirt.

Marcia Perry Dix wearing NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer in shade Hazelnut.

(Image credit: Marcia Perry Dix)

Randi photographed outside wearing Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Foundation in shade 2 with a white shirt.

Randi Becker wears Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Foundation in shade 2.

(Image credit: Marie Claire)

Joele Amster holding Sarah Creal Face Flex in shade 4 near her face with red nail polish.

Joele Amster wears Sarah Creal Face Flex in shade 4.

(Image credit: Joele)

Amber Randolph wearing danessa myricks yummy skin foundation in a denim shirt.

Amber Randolph wears the Daness Myricks Yummy Skin Lift & Flex Hydrating Concealer in shade 7.

(Image credit: Amber Randolph)

Mindy Holender wearing maybelline concealer in front of a chandelier.

Mindy Holender wears Maybelline's Age rewind in shade 120.

(Image credit: Mindy Holender)

Also Recommended

Mindy Holender wearing Kosas concealer in front of a chandelier.

Mindy Holender wears Kosas Revealer Concealer in shade 3.8N.

(Image credit: Marie Claire)

Mindy Holender wearing cle de peau concealer in a black shirt.

(Image credit: Mindy Holender)

Mindy Holender wearing anastasia concealer in a black shirt.

Mindy Holender wears Anastasia Magic Touch Concealer in shade 15.

(Image credit: Mindy Holender)

What to Look for in a Concealer for Mature Skin

As a general rule of thumb, hydrating, radiant concealers are going to work better on mature skin types. “Matte formulas tend to enhance fine lines and can look very harsh on drier skin,” explains makeup artist Michele Shakeshaft. She recommends looking for descriptive words like “creamy” or “blendable” when selecting a product to ensure it lays smoothly.

If you are really in touch with the skincare side, do a quick scan of the product’s INCI list. “Hydrating hyaluronic acid and brightening niacinamide and vitamin C are excellent ingredients to look for in a concealer for the under-eye area,” adds celebrity makeup artist Sofia Tilbury, who has worked with Salma Hayek, Kate Moss, and Penelope Cruz. Glycerin is very hydrating, vitamin E is soothing, and dimethicone will help provide that silky texture. If dark circles are your concern, seek out a formula with caffeine.

Close up of an African American woman posing with the Giorgio Armani Luminous Silk Concealer

The Giorgio Armani Luminous Silk Concealer, Marie Claire's top overall concealer for mature skin, provides a hydrating, luminous finish.

(Image credit: Sephora)

When Do I Apply Concealer on Mature Skin?

Less is more when it comes to concealer, so you should only apply extra coverage where you need it. After applying one of the best primers for mature skin and putting the finishing touches on your foundation, you’ll want to apply concealer to any areas that need color correction or brightness. “Precise coverage will perfect the look of the skin without building texture or creating a heavy look,” notes Shakeshaft.

Do I Need Different Concealers for Different Concerns?

The number of concealers you need in your collection really depends on the intensity of your concerns. By all means, you can use one formula on your under eyes and complexion. That said, you might want to throw a color corrector into the mix. “It’s a great way to cancel out blue, purple, and green pigments in the skin that can otherwise show through your foundation or powder base,” notes Tilbury. These get applied directly after moisturizer. “Let the color corrector dry until it becomes a little tacky and less moveable,” explains Malek. “Then go in with your concealer on a flat brush and blend it out with a beauty blender.”

Woman in a white shirt holding Cle de Peau concealer stick.

The Cle de Peau concealer stick, which was one of Mindy's favorites, doubles as foundation—and contains SPF 27.

(Image credit: Sephora)

What Shade Concealer Do I Choose?

This is largely personal preference. A few years ago, most makeup artists would tell you to go two shades lighter than your foundation in order to brighten the under-eye. Now, the trends have changed slightly. In order to achieve a more natural look, you should pick a concealer that’s one shade lighter. “We are looking to bring that area forward, brighten, and lessen the look of depth,” says Shakeshaft.

Depending on how bright you like your under-eye concealer, you might also want to consider having an alternative, slightly darker concealer on hand for touch ups on the face.

How to Apply Concealer for Mature Skin

Picking the right concealer formula is only half the battle. Knowing the proper way to apply your concealer? That’s equally—if not more—important. “It’s all about building up in sheer layers to achieve your desired coverage and only focusing on using products where you feel that you need it,” notes Tilbury. This slow-and-steady technique ensures that the concealer looks airbrushed and natural anywhere on the skin.

If you’re specifically concerned about applying concealer in the under eye area, Shakeshaft suggests working from the bottom up. “Unless you are trying to neutralize redness in the lash line, don’t take concealer up to the base of the lashes. Apply it at the outer corner of the eye or deepest area of the under eye pocket, then tap it upwards, towards the lash line.”

When it comes to powder, you’re probably better off skipping it altogether, as it can draw attention to fine lines. Shadi suggests using minimal translucent powder with an eyeshadow brush if you need to set your makeup.

Meet the Experts

.
Shadi Malek

Shadi Malek’s career of nearly a decade in the make-up industry is a testament to her passionate practice, one that has resulted in an extensive list of life-long clients. She first began honing her unmistakable style from her home city of Vancouver, Canada. Today she works in one of the world’s major make-up industry hubs, Los Angeles, transforming models, influencers, and brides with her signature artistic method.

Today, Malek infuses every make-up look she creates with her mastery of aesthetic principles and her passion for an individualized approach to every client. Make-up has never been a one-shade fits all field; Shadi Malek has made it her mission to create beautiful, tailored looks that will match every client’s unique visage.

.
Sofia Schwarzkopf-Tilbury

Sofia took on the role of Lead Artist at the Charlotte Tilbury Beauty counter in Selfridge’s, London. Two years later, she began assisting Charlotte with her work as a makeup artist, from fashion shows, including Temperley London, Tom Ford, Donna Karan, Versus Versace and Victoria’s Secret, to the world’s most glamourous red carpet events such as The Golden Globes, The Oscars, The Met Gala, The British Fashion Awards, BAFTAs, and The BRIT Awards. Sofia has also led the makeup direction for beauty editorial (Vogue Netherlands) and cover shoots (Cosmopolitan Middle East). Sofia has worked with VIP clients all over the world, including Sienna Miller, Irina Shayk, Shanina Shaik, Minnie Driver, Karolina Kurkova, and Olivia Palermo.

.
Michele Shakeshaft

Michele is a Pro Artist for Bobbi Brown Cosmetics.

Samantha Holender
Beauty Editor

Samantha Holender is the Beauty Editor at Marie Claire, where she reports on the best new launches, dives into the science behind skincare, and shares the breakdown on the latest and greatest trends in the beauty space. She's studied up on every ingredient you'll find on INCI list and is constantly in search of the world's glowiest makeup products. She's constantly tracking the biggest nail and hair trends to pop up in the beauty space, going backstage during fashion weeks, tracking celebrity looks, and constantly talking to celebrity hair stylists, nail artists, and makeup artists. Prior to joining the team, she worked as Us Weekly’s Beauty and Style Editor, where she stayed on the pulse of pop culture and broke down celebrity beauty routines, hair transformations, and red carpet looks. Her words have also appeared on Popsugar, Makeup.com, Skincare.com, Delish.com, and Philadelphia Wedding. Samantha also serves as a board member for the American Society of Magazine Editors (ASME). She first joined the organization in 2018, when she worked as an editorial intern at Food Network Magazine and Pioneer Woman Magazine. Samantha has a degree in Journalism and Mass Communications from The George Washington University’s School of Media and Public Affairs. While at GWU, she was a founding member of the school’s HerCampus chapter and served as its President for four years. When she’s not deep in the beauty closet or swatching eyeshadows, you can find her obsessing over Real Housewives and all things Bravo. Keep up with her on Instagram @samholender.